Deciding
Is subscription solar worth it?
By Jake Breaux, registered Texas solar salesperson (TDLR) · Updated · Leer en español
The short version
If you're staying twenty years and have the cash, buy the panels. For you, owning usually wins on lifetime cost. Three to fifteen years, or no idea yet, and the subscription is usually the better fit: nothing down, no lien, the provider paying for repairs and insurance, and a commitment that ends at 36 months (5 years in Illinois). Many of the answers online that say no are describing a 10 to 25 year pay-monthly plan, which is a different product.
Is subscription solar worth it?
Usually yes if you'll own the house for three to fifteen years or honestly don't know, and usually no if you can pay cash and you're staying twenty years or more. How long you keep the house decides it, more than any number in the quote.
In that first group you put nothing down, nothing gets filed against your title, and when something breaks the repair is somebody else's bill. If you're certain you're staying twenty five years and you want the asset, buy it and hold the cost floor. That advice comes from somebody who sells subscriptions, so weigh the rest of this page with that in mind.
Why do so many answers say it isn't worth it?
Because plenty of them were written for Britain, Australia or South Africa, about a product that shares the name and little else. A UK installer's guide says most of what's sold there as a solar subscription runs 20 to 25 years. The Australian plan Energy Matters looked at is a monthly fee for ten years, and it concluded the total will almost always cost more than buying outright. For that product the verdict is fair. Two decades of payments is buying the panels in installments, and cash beats installments.
Here, the long contracts are leases and PPAs, usually 20 to 25 years. A rooftop subscription with a 36-month commitment (5 years in Illinois) gets judged on a different question. Total cost across a quarter century matters less than what happens when a job moves you in year four.
So before you trust anybody's verdict, ours included, get four answers about the offer on your table: who owns the panels, how long you're committed (which may not be how long the paper runs), what leaving early costs, and who pays when the inverter dies. If the answers come back "you, twenty years, the balance, you", that's a loan with a friendlier name.
What are the pros and cons of subscription solar?
The pros are nothing down, no lien on the house, repairs and insurance carried by the provider, savings that average around 40% of the bill, and a way out after 36 months (5 years in Illinois). The cons are that you never own the panels, the price goes up 1.9% each year (Illinois locks the rate for 15 years instead), and leaving before the commitment ends is the provider's call.
Pros
- Nothing down. The first bill shows up when the system switches on, not when you sign.
- No lien, and nothing recorded in the county land records.
- The provider owns, insures and repairs the system, so a dead inverter is their problem.
- Savings average around 40% of the current bill. In Texas and Florida that's an estimate, not a promise. Illinois contracts add a minimum 30% savings guarantee, and what you save above that depends on your roof and usage.
- After 36 months (5 years in Illinois) you can leave with no fee, and the provider removes the system at no charge after year 3 in Texas and Florida, year 5 in Illinois.
- Every subscription system in Texas, Florida and Illinois comes with a battery.
Cons
- You never own the panels, so there's no asset at the end.
- The price goes up 1.9% each year, fixed (Illinois locks the rate for 15 years).
- Leaving inside the commitment is up to the provider, not a right you hold.
- The utility's grid connection charge stays on your bill either way.
- You need a credit score around 650 and a home you own and live in. Renters and condo owners can't sign up.
- A cash buyer who stays twenty years usually comes out ahead by buying.
Isn't buying the panels always the better deal?
For some people it still is. Before this year I told cash buyers who planned to stay put that buying outright for the 30% credit beat a third-party option. That homeowner credit is gone for new installs, so that reason went with it. What's left is ownership itself, which is worth paying for if you're staying twenty years and have the cash. Ask a CPA how your own taxes treat any of it.
The full cash, loan and lease math is atsolar lease vs loan vs cash.
In Texas the answer shifts a little, because power there costs less than the U.S. average. Is solar worth it in Texas? runs those numbers.
One more piece of old advice runs backwards now. Sellers used to hear that moving soon was a reason to skip solar. With a subscription it's closer to a reason to sign one: no balance to pay off, nothing for a buyer to qualify for, and no filing in the county land records.
Is a solar subscription the same as community solar?
No, though search results mix the two up all the time. Community solar is a share of a solar farm somewhere else. You subscribe to part of what the array produces, and the dollar value comes back as a credit on your electric bill, which is how theDepartment of Energydescribes it. Nothing goes on your roof, so renters can join where a program exists.
A rooftop subscription puts panels on your own house. That means a credit check, a home you own and live in, and a 36-month commitment (5 years in Illinois). If you rent, or your roof won't work, look at community solar instead. The full comparison is atcommunity solar vs subscription solar.
Who should not subscribe to solar?
Start with the no, because it's the shorter list. If you can pay cash and you're confident you're staying in the house for twenty years, ownership usually wins on lifetime cost. If the roof needs replacing, do the roof first. Heavy shade, a credit file under about 650, renting, a condo, or panels already up there: all noes.
That list goes first on purpose. Put a subscription on a roof that needed a roofer and the problem comes back later, with interest. Anybody telling you this fits everyone hasn't asked you enough questions yet.
What does it cost, and what do you save?
Nothing up front, and the first bill arrives when the system switches on, not when you sign. Typical savings run around 40% of the current electric bill, so roughly $120 a month on a $300 bill. In Texas and Florida that's an estimate rather than a promise, and it moves with your roof, your shade and your usage. Illinois contracts include a minimum 30% savings guarantee, and what you save above it depends on your roof and usage.
A small grid connection charge from the utility stays on your account either way. Ask what yours is. It doesn't go away, and quotes have a habit of leaving it out.
Then ask for two numbers before you compare anything to anything: what the subscription costs in month one, and what it costs in month 120 after the 1.9% yearly increase has compounded. In Illinois those two match, because the rate is locked for 15 years (the Illinois terms). Any quote worth reading can produce both in a minute. Then test the savings claim, ours included, against what power really costs where you live (EIA Electric Power Monthly), and check the production assumption underneath it withthe federal PVWatts calculator. Both cost nothing, and neither one is selling you anything.
The four ways to get panels, side by side
| Structure | Upfront | Lien on the home | Term | At sale |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cash | Full system cost | None | None | Easy, the panels are yours to sell with the house |
| Solar loan | $0 to some | Usually a UCC fixture filing | 10 to 25 years | Pay it off at closing, or the buyer takes on the loan |
| Lease or PPA | $0 | Often | 20 to 25 years | Buyer has to qualify and assume, or you buy the contract out |
| Subscription | $0 | None | 36 months (5 years in Illinois) | Walk after month 36 (year 5 in Illinois), nothing for a buyer to assume |
Read the "at sale" column from the top. Every row above the subscription is a negotiation; the subscription row is a phone call. What the bottom row doesn't give you is ownership, and if ownership is what you're after, the top row is the honest recommendation. The structure-by-structure version is atsolar lease vs subscription.
What's the catch in the contract?
Two of them, and both live in the paper rather than the pitch. The commitment runs 36 months (in Illinois, 5 years). After that there's no fee to cancel, and leaving before then is the provider's call. The second is the escalator: 1.9% a year, fixed, in Texas and Florida. It's small and it's disclosed, but it's there. Illinois skips it, because the rate is locked for 15 years.
$150 at 1.9% a year becomes about $156 by month 36, about 3.8% in total. A lease escalator of 2.9% to 3.9% running for twenty five years is a different animal, and that gap is most of the argument for this product, which is why we name our own number before anyone asks. The long version is atsolar escalator clauses. Whoever is selling to you, make them put a finger on the cancellation clause, including what the provider may choose to do if you leave inside the first three years. That part is discretionary, not promised. How the exits compare across contract types is atcancelling a solar contract.
What happens when you sell the house?
Very little. There's no lien to clear and no balance to pay off, so the closing doesn't wait on a finance company's paperwork. If the buyer wants the panels they can subscribe in their own name. Nobody is obligated to. If they don't want them, the provider takes the system off and repairs what it touched, at no charge to the seller after year 3 in Texas and Florida, year 5 in Illinois.
That second case is rarer than sellers expect. In Texas, about 92% of the time a home sells with one of these systems on the roof, the buyer keeps it. The 8% who don't are usually tearing the house down or gutting it.
Set that against the lease version, where a buyer has to qualify for a contract they didn't choose, and deals die in the inspection period over panels neither side wanted. The closing-table breakdown, structure by structure, is atselling a house with solar.
Get your number
No article can answer this for you, including this one. The number that settles it is your own bill against your own roof. Run your bill through the estimator and a real person follows up with figures for your address. If you want the mechanics first, start withhow the model works, or read the catch inwhat $0 down really means. And if the federal tax credit is the reason you're shopping at all, read what changed with the 30% credit before you assume it's still waiting for you.
Sources
Subscription solar is our business, so don't take our word for the contract mechanics. These are the primary sources: check them.
- Electric Power Monthly, Table 5.6.A: average price of electricity by state, U.S. Energy Information Administration
The federal government's own figures for what residential electricity costs in your state. Check any savings claim against it, including ours.
- Homeowner's Guide to Going Solar, U.S. Department of Energy
A plain-language walk through ownership, leases and PPAs, written by a party with nothing to sell you.
- PVWatts Calculator, National Laboratory of the Rockies (formerly NREL), U.S. Department of Energy
The federal lab's production estimator. Enter your address and roof and see roughly what a system there should make, before anyone quotes you a savings number built on it.
- Solar Power for Your Home, Federal Trade Commission
The FTC on solar sales: what to ask, what to get in writing, and which pitches are worth walking away from.
- Buyer's Remorse: The FTC's Cooling-Off Rule May Help, Federal Trade Commission
If you signed at your own kitchen table, federal law may give you three business days to cancel. Several states add their own window on top.
- Community Solar Basics, U.S. Department of Energy
The federal definition of community solar: a share of an off-site array, paid back as a credit on your electric bill. Read it to tell that product apart from panels on your own roof.
- Solar Subscriptions: Are They Worth It?, Heatable (UK installer)
How the word is used in Britain, where most agreements sold as solar subscriptions run 20 to 25 years. Useful for seeing why British answers to this question land on no.
- Is Subscription Solar a Lifeline or a Long Bill?, Energy Matters (Australia)
The case against a ten-year Australian subscription plan, whose total it says will almost always exceed the cost of buying outright. Fair for that product.
Want the numbers for your actual roof?
See your roof's numbers