Home batteries
Home battery or generator: which wins for power outages?
By Jake Breaux, registered Texas solar salesperson (TDLR) · Updated
The short version
A generator makes its own power by burning fuel and can run as long as fuel keeps arriving. A battery stores power made earlier and drains once that runs out, unless solar or the grid refills it. Generators cost less upfront and run longer on a single tank; batteries are quieter, need almost no maintenance and produce no exhaust. Neither replaces the other for every outage. This page compares them plainly: fuel, noise, maintenance, permits, what each can power, and the carbon monoxide risk a lot of generator buyers underrate.
What's the real difference between a home battery and a generator?
A generator makes its own electricity by burning fuel, gasoline, propane or diesel, whenever you need it; a battery stores electricity made earlier, by the grid or by solar panels, and releases it when the power goes out. A generator can run as long as fuel keeps arriving. A battery has a fixed amount of stored energy and drains once that runs out, unless something recharges it.
How long will each one keep the lights on?
A generator runs until it runs out of fuel, and you can keep it going by refueling, so its limit is really how much fuel you can store or buy. A home battery holds a fixed amount of energy and drains faster the more you run, so its runtime depends on your usage and shrinks with every appliance you add.
If solar is charging the battery, the math changes: on a sunny day the panels can run the house and refill the battery at the same time, so the battery only has to cover the dark hours instead of the whole outage.The battery runtime calculator works both cases from your own bill, with and without solar.
What does each one cost, to buy and to run?
A portable generator is the cheapest way in; a permanently installed standby generator costs more, plus a concrete pad and wiring. Fuel adds to that every time it runs. A home battery bought outright costs more upfront still, but it burns no fuel and needs almost no running cost beyond the electricity used to charge it.
How loud is a generator, and does a battery make any noise?
A portable generator at normal load is loud enough to carry across a yard and through a wall, the kind of noise that gets a neighbor's attention during a quiet, powerless night. A standby generator in an enclosure is quieter but still audible outside. A battery has no engine, so it makes no running noise at all beyond a faint internal fan on some models.
What maintenance does each one need?
A generator has an engine, so it needs the same care any small engine does: fresh fuel, regular oil changes, a charged starter battery, and a yearly test run so it is not dead the one week you need it. A home battery has no engine to wear out and needs little beyond the software updates and inspections the installer schedules.
Do you need a permit for either one?
Usually yes, for anything permanently wired into the house. A standby generator typically needs an electrical permit and a sign at the main panel noting the alternate power source, under the National Electrical Code; local rules add setback and exhaust distances on top of that. A home battery installed by a licensed electrician needs its own electrical permit, and some cities require fire department sign-off too.
A Florida building department's own generator rules show what that looks like in practice: a minimum clearance from doors and windows, a minimum distance from a propane tank's fill valve, and exhaust kept away from anything that could pull fumes indoors (Leon County, Florida). Rules vary by city and county; check with your own building department before you buy.
Is carbon monoxide really a risk with a generator?
Yes. The CPSC counts more than 80 deaths a year from portable-generator carbon monoxide. A generator's exhaust can build lethal carbon monoxide in a garage or near a window within minutes, even with the door open. Federal regulators have required a carbon monoxide warning label on portable generators made or imported since May 2007, and still tell owners to keep one at least 20 feet from doors and windows. A battery produces no exhaust at all.
The CDC's own guidance is blunt about it: never run a generator inside your home, garage or carport, and keep it outside at least 20 feet from doors, windows and vents. If you buy a generator, buy a carbon monoxide alarm with it.
What can each one power?
A small portable generator covers a refrigerator, some lights and a window unit; a larger one or a standby unit can run central air and most of a house. A home battery is sized in energy, not just output, so a battery that can run the air conditioner for an hour might not get you through the night; check both the power rating and the stored energy before you decide.
How do a generator and a battery compare, side by side?
Neither one wins on every measure, which is the point of putting them side by side instead of picking a favorite. Fuel supply, noise, upfront cost and what happens on a cloudy week after a storm all pull in different directions, and the right call depends on how long your outages run and what you need powered.
| Generator | Battery | |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel | Gasoline, propane or diesel; needs resupply | None; charges from the grid or solar |
| Runtime limit | However much fuel you can get | Fixed stored energy, drains with use |
| Noise | Audible, often loud at full load | No engine noise; a faint fan on some models |
| Upfront cost | Low (portable) to moderate (standby) | Highest, if you buy one outright |
| Running cost | Fuel every time it runs | Mostly the electricity to recharge it |
| Maintenance | Oil, fuel, starter battery, test runs | Minimal; no engine |
| Carbon monoxide | Real hazard; needs an alarm and distance | None |
| Works with solar | No | Yes, recharges from panels |
| Starts automatically | Only standby models with a transfer switch | Yes, typically instant or near-instant |
Which one makes sense for your house?
If your outages are rare and short, a portable generator for the fridge and a few lights is the cheapest insurance you can buy. If outages run long, you want backup to start without you standing outside in a storm, or you already have or want solar, a battery earns its higher price. Plenty of households reasonably own both.
For how often and how long outages run near you, the numbers are onTexas power outages by utility: an ordinary year is short enough that either option covers it. The bad years run for days, and then it comes down to supply: a generator needs fuel delivered, and a battery needs sun to refill it.
Where does a home battery fit with a solar subscription?
Our subscription systems are generally sized to make more than the home uses in a year, where the roof has room for it, and every subscription system in Texas, Florida and Illinois comes with a battery. That makes it full home backup: the panels run the house by day and refill the battery, and the battery carries the night.
In most outages that setup is as reliable as a generator, or more. There's no fuel to run out of and no engine to start. Its weak spot is a run of heavy cloud right after a storm, when the panels make less and the battery has to stretch.
In Houston, four companies publish home battery or solar-and-battery offers. Home battery backup in Houston puts what each one publishes about upfront cost, monthly fee and term side by side.
On my own house: the power lines in my neighborhood run above ground, and we lose power a lot. One outage left the neighborhood dark for seven days. I have the same kind of system on my house, and I haven't lost power in four years.
Run your bill through the estimator to see what your own roof would come to, or work through your exact numbers first on the runtime calculator.
Sources
Subscription solar is our business, so don't take our word for the contract mechanics. These are the primary sources: check them.
- Avoiding Carbon Monoxide Poisoning, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
Federal guidance never to use a generator inside a home, garage or carport, and to keep it outside at least 20 feet from doors, windows and vents. Read 2026-10-19.
- Portable Generators; Labeling Requirements (final rule), 16 CFR Part 1407, U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission
The federal rule requiring a carbon monoxide hazard warning label on portable generators manufactured or imported on or after May 14, 2007.
- What to Know: Generators, U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission
The agency's own consumer safety sheet on generator carbon monoxide risk and safe operating distance. It counts more than 80 consumer deaths a year from carbon monoxide poisoning caused by portable generators.
- Generators for Back-Up Power During Outages, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Building America Solution Center (U.S. Department of Energy)
DOE-funded guidance on sizing, fuel types and running costs for home backup generators.
- Generator Requirements for FBC 8th Edition (2023) and NEC 2020, Leon County, Florida, Development Services (Building Division)
A Florida building department's permit, setback and exhaust requirements for a permanently installed generator under the National Electrical Code.
- Residential Energy Storage System Regulations, National Fire Protection Association
NFPA's own explanation of how NFPA 855 treats home battery storage, including when fire department review applies.
Want the numbers for your actual roof?
See your roof's numbers